7 signs you might need a rebrand. PART 3
In Part 1 and Part 2 we covered the first 5 signs that could indicate you need a rebrand. We discuseed the trouble your team might have describing what you do, the impact of pricing pressures and lengthing sales cycles. Then we looked the barriers to cross selling and finally what might be happening with your win rate. This article we cover the final two signs.
6. You've merged, acquired, been acquired, or taken investment
Nothing raises the brand question faster than a change of ownership or new investment. A new acquisition prompts questions of what to do with the new brand. Do you keep it? Do you merge it? What are the risks? New investment often brings a new commercial direction, energy and vision the current brand can’t match.
I joined The Key Group as Marketing Director in 2017, at the start of a four-year investment cycle, and the work needed on the portfolio and the story was clear.
The Key had begun life as a government-funded pilot, so its history was in the not-for-profit world. By the time I arrived, it had taken on private investment, which expected significant commercial growth and required both a brand review and a change in internal culture.
The task was to bring everyone, staff, customers and wider stakeholders, onto the same page with a new brand narrative for the next stage of growth. The rebrand was never only about our visual identity, which was important. But it involved finding a core message, a guiding principle that could bring everyone in the company together and galvanise growth.
We created a guiding principle, The Knowledge to Act, and it became a lens we could hold over everything. A decision-making framework in one sentence. Does this piece of content give a headteacher the knowledge to act? Does this software deliver the information and insight a SENCO needs to act? It gave every team, and every decision, the same test to apply.
The results speak for themselves. We grew market share from 36% to 57%, resulting in a successful exit.
7. You sound exactly like your competitors
Here's a test you can run right now. Open your homepage and your three closest competitors' homepages. Cover the logos. Can you tell which one is yours?
If the words are similar, the promises about outcomes are the same, the claim to be trusted by schools is the same, and the verbs remain the same, then your brand isn't differentiating you. Sameness is the default state of any category. Every company drifts toward safe, expected language over time because buyers already understand it. Standing out takes a deliberate decision to say something different.
The result is that everything is just a bit harder than it should be. A bit harder to get noticed, a bit harder to be remembered, a bit harder to justify a premium. You haven't given your buyer a reason why you are different. Worthy of consideration. You are just one more option on the list.
When it isn't a rebrand
I said at the top that a rebrand might not be your answer. Three situations look like rebrand triggers and usually aren't.
A logo that just looks dated. If your positioning is sound, your team tells a consistent story, and the only real problem is that the visual identity has aged, you need a visual refresh, not a rebrand. It's cheaper, faster and lower-risk. Don't let yourself be talked into a strategy project you don't need.
A lead-generation problem. If the pipeline is thin, the brand may be perfectly fine, and the demand-generation engine may be the issue: targeting, channels, offer, follow-up. A rebrand won't fix a mechanics problem, and it's an expensive way to avoid looking at your funnel.
A sales-enablement gap. If deals are stalling because your salespeople can't handle objections or don't have the right materials, that's training and tooling. A new brand gives them better raw material to work with, but it doesn't teach them how to sell.
Knowing when not to invest in a rebrand is arguably more useful than anything else in this series.
Not sure which one you're looking at?
It can be hard to read the signals. I've built a short rebrand diagnostic that scores where you actually sit and tells you, honestly, whether a rebrand is the right call or a waste of money. It takes a few minutes, and if the answer is "you don't need one," it'll say so.
Comments